We did the math for you; these are the BEST mascara madness deals!

Quick version: right now during mascara madness you can take up to 34% off select individual mascaras here, or BOGO 50% off select mascaras here! We calculated which deals are the BEST bang for your buck for each mascara below.

One of our FAVORITE sales that only pops up a couple times a year is HERE – Mascara Madness! It's the BEST day of the year to stock up on all your favorite mascaras.

Don't know which ones to get? Think these will be too expensive? Keep reading because we'll show you our faves AND how to get the best deals, even at drugstore mascara prices!!!

mascara madness
Photos by Arielle Levy

Mascara Madness deal details

This weekend only when you buy a full size tube of your favorite mascara, you can get another one for 50% OFF! OR take up to 34% off your favorite individual mascaras here. We've done all the research for you and figured out which deal is BEST for each particular mascara, so shop easy using this post!

We know you might be saying that you can’t afford department store mascara, but Corrine's first pick and hands-down favorite is almost the same price as drugstore mascara when you buy it today!!

best deals

Corrine's top Mascara Madness pick – best for overall volume + lengthening

IT Cosmetics Superhero mascara: this has been a serious fave of Corrine's for the past few years. It's one of her top three favorite mascaras!! It gives INCREDIBLE volume but isn't super clumpy and right now you can 2 tubes for only $39! (Reg. $52 for 2)

She loves how gentle yet lengthening it is. It's gentle enough that it washes off super easily, but it really gives you SUPER DRAMATIC lengthening and thickening, making every little lash POP.

it cosmetics mascara

Best mascara madness deal for sensitive eyes

Clinique High Impact Mascara: this mascara really makes your lashes POP with its formula but it's also made to be comfortable on sensitive eyes! It comes off super easily, which was important to Corrine especially when she used to get lash extensions done at a salon and (gasp!) sometimes wear mascara over them. Yes, she did that.

With traditional lash extensions that you get every few weeks, in between fills at the end when they’d start to look a little sparse. or occasionally when she was going to get pictures taken or have a really special night out, she'd put a light coat of Clinique High Impact Mascara over her lash extensions and it fills everything in just enough to make them all stand out, even the little lashes that don’t have an extension if that makes sense. Every time she did this – without fail – someone would say, “WOW are your lashes real? They look SO GOOD.”

Corrine wouldn’t recommend this daily BUT having said that, every time she washed her makeup off after wearing this on her lash extensions, gently with baby shampoo, it comes off just fine and her lash extensions stay on! Can’t say the same for a couple other mascaras she's tried over traditional lash extensions.

*New edit: if you're using Corrine's favorite AT HOME lash extensions that she talks about in this post, she would definitely not recommend using this mascara over those. You don't need it!! 🙂

If you don't wear lash extensions, this is definitely one of the gentlest formulas you can get if you wear contact lenses, or have very sensitive eyes.

FROM: How to do a dewy makeup look

When you buy Clinique High Impact Mascara today during mascara madness you’ll get 34% OFF making it just $15, and we're pretty sure most grocery store mascaras are now around $8-$10 (right?) so for a few dollars more we think it’s TOTALLY worth it. Plus when you buy during this deal it lasts 6 months if you wear it daily, and all year if you're only wearing it occasionally. This is SUCH a steal of a deal!

clinique mascara

Highest Rated Mascara

Lancome Definicils High Definition Mascara: if you're looking for one of the highest recommended mascara by reviewers, this Lancome Definicils is by far the highest-rated mascara with more than 3k almost ALL perfect reviews. This stuff is a little more spendy at $33 a pop, but definitely worth it if you’re willing to invest. And right now during mascara madness you can get 2 of them for only $49.50! (Reg. $66 for 2)

The best thing about Lancome Definicils Mascara is that it never ever clumps, it'll make all your lashes stand out without ever becoming a spidery mess. Here’s a picture of Corrine's beautiful friend Carlie Stylez wearing her Lancome Defincils (PS you should watch + subscribe to her youtube she’s amazing and hilar!)


The Best Clean Mascara

If you've been searching high and low for the best CLEAN mascara, the search ends here. Enter: ILIA's Limitless Lash Mascara. This #1 selling mascara is 99% natural and is basically the only clean mascara that lives up to its name! It was gentle enough to layer on Corrine's lash extensions in the past but powerful enough to really amplify her tiny little bottom lashes. She can totally see why it won Allure's #1 Best Clean Mascara AND a Glamour Beauty Award!!! Celebrities and makeup artists alike have swooned over its ability to lift, thicken, and lengthen PLUS it has keratin in it to nourish the lashes!

Right now during this BOGO 50% off mascara madness deal you can get 2 tubes of this clean mascara for only $42! (Reg. $56 for 2)

ilia clean mascara
FROM: CLEAN beauty that actually works!!
Photo by Arielle Levy

Great for Conditioning

This Grande Lash mascara is amazing if you really want to take care of your natural lashes. Not only does this formula give you rich, bold lashes, but it also has a ton of great ingredients to condition your lashes and prevent breakage. Normally $50 for 2, you can get 2 tubes of this conditioning mascara for only $37.50!

Best Bang for Your Buck – 66% OFF!

If you're looking for the best bang for your buck during Mascara Madness, this tarte mascara bestsellers set is the deal for you today! If you're a big tarte makeup fan, this is an absolutely insane deal and the perfect time to stock up at ONLY $24. Three mascara tubes for the price of one? YES PLEASE.

This set has a $72 value, but right now you can get it for only $24! That's 66% OFF!

tarte mascara

Best for Stimulating Growth + Volume

Urban Decay Perversion mascara is a cult favorite and super highly rated. It even includes marine glycogen which is known to stimulate lash growth. Who's not looking for that little bonus? It's an ultra creamy, lengthening, volumizing, and super dark black mascara. Yes, yes, yes, and YES.

Get 2 tubes for only $42 (reg. $56) during this BOGO 50% off deal!

urban decay proversion mascara
FROM: MAJOR Urban Decay sale! Stock up on your faves!
Photo by Arielle Levy

Best Tubing Mascara

Do you know what tubing mascara is? Instead of putting single layers of mascara below or above your lashes, the mascara literally tubes each individual lash leaving them less clumpy, and the mascara lasts longer throughout the day. Get 2 tubes of this Blinc mascara for only $39! (Reg. $52)

Don't Miss Out

Dont forget that right now you can take up to 34% off select individual mascaras here, or BOGO 50% off select mascara here!!!!!! This event only happens a couple times a year so make sure you grab your faves before the sale is over.

Which mascara is your favorite? Let us know in the comments!

Up to 34% off individuals

Mascara Madness BOGO 50% off

Corrine Stokoe

Corrine Stokoe is a blogger, podcaster and content creator behind the brand Mint Arrow. She and her husband Neil live in South Orange County with their 5 kids, she runs her blog and business with 7 team members, where they find the best daily deals and share favorite finds in fashion and beauty. They also run a podcast called Mint Arrow Messages. Mint Arrow has been featured in Forbes, Women's Wear Daily, Business Insider, The Wall Street Journal, AdWeek and Allure. Corrine is passionate about sharing the gospel of Jesus Christ as often as she can and teaching others to use social media for good.

Related Content

Never Miss a Deal
Hi, I’m Corrine and it’s pretty simple. I think you deserve to buy the things you want at a price you can afford. Here you can find the best deals and steals on high end fashion, as well as beauty and wellness tutorials.


  1. Total bummer, the sale is over before midnight tonight. I’ll have to keep an eye out for the next time this sale comes around!

  2. This is great! I need a new mascara and ordered the Clinique after reading this. Thanks for sharing!

  3. I stocked up on the Urban Decay Perversion since it was so universally highly rated. Thanks for the tip on the great sale! Hopefully next year I can branch out and try different ones.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.